← LinkedIn · Versiunea în română

In an open tender, the bidder ALFA appears in SEAP (the Romanian electronic public procurement system) with a negative finding document issued 18 months ago. The finding document (document constatator) is the document in which the contracting authority records how the contractor performed its obligations under a contract and, where applicable, any damage caused. ALFA’s previous contract had been terminated early after repeated delays, and the authority had applied penalties.
ALFA challenged the document in court, without obtaining a suspension of its effects. At the same time, it submits evidence of payment of the penalties, replacement of its operational management and introduction of an internal system for monitoring contract performance.
Decision questions
Does challenging the finding document prevent its use in the evaluation?
Does the negative document automatically lead to ALFA’s exclusion?
May the authority exclude the bidder without assessing the remedial measures?
Model answer
1. NO. A mere challenge does not suspend the effects of the finding document. Under Article 166(4) of the Annex to Government Decision (GD) no. 395/2016, finding documents issued in accordance with paragraphs (1) and (2) may be challenged under Law no. 554/2004. In the form in force, special jurisdiction lies with the administrative and fiscal litigation section of the tribunal, within 30 days from communication to the contractor — Article 53(1³) of Law no. 101/2016, introduced by Law no. 208/2022. The only available remedy is an appeal on points of law (recurs), within 10 days, under Article 55(3¹) of the same law, as amended by Law no. 75/2023.
Article 166(5) of the Annex to GD no. 395/2016 governs the publication in SEAP of finding documents issued for non-performance of contractual obligations, within 60 days from the date of issue, “except where the effects have been suspended by a court judgment”. The text thus recognises only a suspension ordered by a court, not an automatic suspensive effect of the action. Nor does Law no. 101/2016 provide that bringing an action suspends the effects of the document by operation of law; Article 53(2) refers to suspension of the performance of the contract, not of the finding document. Suspension of the document’s effects may be requested from the court. For a request to suspend the enforcement of a unilateral administrative act, the general framework is Articles 14 and 15 of Law no. 554/2004: duly justified cases and the prevention of imminent damage. Unless it is suspended or annulled, the document continues to produce effects and may be examined by the evaluation committee.
2. NO, not automatically. To apply Article 167(1)(g) of Law no. 98/2016, the authority must establish, cumulatively, that:
- the economic operator has seriously or repeatedly breached its main obligations under a previously concluded public procurement, sectoral or concession contract
- those breaches led to the early termination of that contract, to the payment of damages or to other comparable sanctions.
The legal text does not add, as a third cumulative condition, the requirement that the facts be “attributable” to the operator or “sufficiently relevant to its current credibility”. Credibility is assessed, as the case may be, within the remedial measures provided for in Article 171.
The finding document is an important means of evidence, but the committee must analyse the specific situation, not merely the existence of a negative entry in SEAP. Under Article 166(8) of the Annex to GD no. 395/2016, when it rejects a candidate or a bidder on the basis of such a document, the committee must analyse whether the document reflects the cumulative conditions of Article 167(1)(g). In this case, the committee must also check whether the penalties applied fall within “the payment of damages or other comparable sanctions”. Article 167(8) lists, by way of example, as serious breaches of contractual obligations, failure to perform the contract and the supply, provision or execution of products, services or works with major non-conformities that make them unfit for use in accordance with the purpose set out in the contract.
Under Article 171(5)(b), where the economic operator has not been barred by a final judgment from participating in award procedures, the situations in Article 167 no longer apply once a period of 3 years has elapsed from the date on which the situation arose, the act was committed or the relevant event occurred. The period does not, in itself, run from the date of issue of the finding document. In this case, the document was issued 18 months ago, after the early termination; the 3-year period has not elapsed.
3. NO. ALFA is entitled to submit evidence that it has restored its credibility — Article 171(1). If that evidence is sufficient, the authority does not exclude it, under paragraph (2).
Payment of, or undertaking to pay, compensation, full clarification of the facts and concrete and appropriate technical, organisational and personnel measures are relevant under Article 171(3). The authority must assess them taking into account the gravity and the particular circumstances of the misconduct — paragraph (3¹). If it considers them insufficient, it must send the operator a statement of the reasons for the exclusion decision — paragraph (3²).
Replacing the management and introducing internal controls are relevant, but not sufficient merely by being listed: ALFA must prove their actual implementation and their link to preventing the misconduct from recurring.
Currency reservation
The legislative form was verified on 22 November 2026:
- Article 166(4) and (5) of the Annex to GD no. 395/2016 was amended by GD no. 336/2023, published in Official Gazette (M.Of.) no. 328/19.04.2023; paragraph (5) had previously also been amended by GD no. 375/2022
- Article 166(5²)–(5⁴), concerning documents issued during performance, was introduced by GD no. 375/2022, published in M.Of. no. 277/22.03.2022; these paragraphs do not change the obligation of a specific assessment
- the finding document is currently challenged before the administrative and fiscal litigation section of the tribunal, within 30 days from communication — Article 53(1³) of Law no. 101/2016, introduced by Law no. 208/2022, published in M.Of. no. 697/12.07.2022, in force since 10.09.2022; the only remedy is an appeal on points of law, within 10 days — Article 55(3¹), as amended by Law no. 75/2023, published in M.Of. no. 276/03.04.2023
- Article 171(3¹)–(3²) of Law no. 98/2016 was introduced by Government Emergency Ordinance (GEO) no. 114/2020, published in M.Of. no. 614/13.07.2020
- the decisive provisions — Article 167(1)(g) and (8) and Article 171(1)–(3) and (5)(b) — are not shown as repealed in the official form verified; GEO no. 52/2024, published in M.Of. no. 483/24.05.2024, does not amend them.
Practical verdict
- Does a mere challenge remove the effects of the finding document? — NO.
- Does every negative finding document lead to automatic exclusion? — NO.
- Must the “self-cleaning” measures be assessed? — YES.
- May ALFA be excluded if the measures are insufficient and the conditions of Article 167(1)(g) are met? — YES, by a reasoned decision.
Official sources: Law no. 98/2016 – Legislative Portal · GD no. 395/2016 – consolidated form · GEO no. 114/2020 · Law no. 101/2016 · Law no. 554/2004 · HCCJ Decision no. 25/2021 (full reasoning)
Note
In brief. The decision clarifies which court hears challenges to the negative finding document, that is, the document in which the authority records that the company did not perform its contract and allegedly caused damage. The answer of the High Court of Cassation and Justice (HCCJ), valid at the date of the decision, was the civil court, not the administrative litigation court. The legislature has since changed the rule. Today, the finding document is challenged before the administrative litigation court (see the last section).

The problem. Courts were giving different solutions. Some heard these disputes as administrative litigation, under Law no. 554/2004, treating the document as an administrative act. Others sent them to the civil court, as disputes arising from the performance of the contract. The Court of Appeal of Iași referred an appeal in the interest of the law to the HCCJ (case no. 2469/1/2021). HCCJ Decision no. 25/2021, together with its reasoning, was published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 180 of 23 February 2022.
What the HCCJ decided (Decision no. 25 of 15 November 2021). It upheld the appeal and held that an action for annulment of the finding document falls within the jurisdiction of the civil court, under:
- Article 53(1¹) of Law no. 101/2016, which, in its form at that time, assigned disputes concerning the performance of public procurement contracts to the civil court
- Article 8(2) of Law no. 554/2004, under which disputes arising from the performance of administrative contracts fall within the jurisdiction of the ordinary civil courts.
The provisions interpreted were Article 166 of GD no. 395/2016, for contracts awarded under Law no. 98/2016, and Article 97¹ of GD no. 925/2006, for older contracts awarded under GEO no. 34/2006. Both were read in relation to Article 2(1)(c) of Law no. 554/2004, which defines the administrative act. Article 166 was subsequently amended by GD no. 375/2022 and GD no. 336/2023.
The Court’s main arguments:
- Jurisdiction did not depend on the legal nature of the finding document. What mattered was the will of the legislature, which, at that date, had assigned disputes arising from the performance of the contract to the civil courts (paras. 35 and 40).
- Law no. 212/2018 had reintroduced the division of jurisdiction. Administrative litigation retained damages arising from the award procedure and the setting aside of the contract, while disputes arising from performance moved to the civil court. The same law amended Article 8(2) of Law no. 554/2004 (para. 39).
- The finding document is drawn up during performance, is not part of the award procedure and is not equivalent to a request to set aside the contract (para. 40).
- The solution was the same for contracts concluded under GEO no. 34/2006 and under Law no. 98/2016, if the dispute began after Law no. 212/2018 entered into force (paras. 42–43).
- The “challenge” (contestație) in Article 166 of GD no. 395/2016 does not mean the challenge procedure under Law no. 101/2016. The Norms recognise only the right to go to court (para. 44).
- The reference in the government decisions to Law no. 554/2004 was a lack of legislative correlation. The law applies, as the higher-ranking rule (para. 45).
- The Prosecutor General requested the same solution (paras. 17–20).
The rule in force today (verified on 22 November 2026). The decision has been overtaken by legislation:
- Law no. 208/2022 (M.Of. no. 697 of 12.07.2022), in force since 10.09.2022, introduced Article 53(1³) into Law no. 101/2016. The finding document is challenged before the administrative and fiscal litigation section of the tribunal, within 30 days from communication to the contractor.
- Law no. 75/2023 (M.Of. no. 276 of 3.04.2023), in force since 6.04.2023, replaced, in Article 53(1¹), “the civil section” with “the administrative and fiscal litigation section”. It also provided that the judgment concerning the finding document may be challenged only by an appeal on points of law, within 10 days (Article 55(3¹)).
- HCCJ Decision no. 11/2023 (M.Of. no. 753 of 18.08.2023) confirms the jurisdiction of the administrative litigation courts for applications filed after 10.09.2022.
In practice, a finding document issued today is challenged before the administrative and fiscal litigation section of the tribunal, within 30 days from communication. The judgment may be challenged only by an appeal on points of law, within 10 days.
Continuation HERE.
Reference
Slimac, O. (2026, November 22). Case of the week — The negative finding document and “self-cleaning”. LinkedIn.


Trebuie să fii autentificat pentru a publica un comentariu.