← Academia · Versiunea în română
Translated from Romanian by Achiziții Corecte. The Romanian text is the reference version.
This material neither promises nor guarantees you success
Identify the Procurement Method
- The procurement method bears different names for each category
In general, the procurement of goods and works is different from that of services, and there are specific methods for each category.
Key idea:
Regardless of the category it belongs to and whatever name we give the method, methods fall into two broad categories: competitive and non-competitive
Table 1 – Procurement methods
| Competitive | Non-Competitive |
|---|---|
| Open tender (OT) | Restricted (selective) tender |
| Request for proposals (RfP) | Request for quotations (small contracts, three offers) |
| Two-stage tender | Direct purchase (single source) |
Public procurement methods are paths, more or less mysterious (friendsi know why), by which the contracting authority (entity) will purchase (buy) goods, services and works.
Table 2 – Types of public contracts
| Public works contracts | Public service contracts | Public supply contracts |
|---|---|---|
| Public contracts having as their object either the execution, or both the design and execution, of works, for example building or civil engineering works, such as a road or a waste-water treatment plant. | Public contracts other than public works or supply contracts having as their object the provision of services, such as consultancy, training or cleaning services. | Public contracts having as their object the purchase, lease, rental or hire-purchase, with or without an option to buy, of products such as stationery, vehicles or computers. |
| Detailed list of works in Annex II to the directive | Detailed list of services in Annex XIV to the directive |
The system thus built aims to allow access to the Public Procurement Market (PPM) only to those economic operators capable of executing, providing and supplying the products, services and works that reflect and ensure exact coverage of the Buyer’s need, and to exclude those incapable of entering into a correct relationship with the contracting authority (entity).
The existence of exclusion criteria and of a selection regime for economic operators is a common, ordinary measure in all major procurement systems, and they are considered genuinely necessary requirements in all the public procurement systems of all the Member States of the European Union.
So we have: the grounds for exclusion, the selection criteria and the reduction of the number of candidates.
Exclusion aims to protect the Buyer’s legitimate interests by preventing the participation of undesirable economic operators in these procedures, but also by preventing possible acts of corruption that could lead to unprofessional behaviour or undermine the credibility of the purchasing entity; even so, economic operators have the possibility of clarifying negative aspects before a final decision is taken.
Competitive methods are always preferable because they tend to promote transparency, effectiveness and efficiency and to limit favouritism (see the Principle of Correct Procurement).
Procurement Methods
There are several public procurement methods, generally classified under the definitions given by the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, UNCITRALii:
- Open tender,
- Request for proposals,
- Two-stage tender,
- Restricted tender,
- Request for quotations and
- Direct purchase
Of these, the first three are considered Competitive because access to the competition is ensured for all and any interested economic operator (they are public on the SICAPiii website and on the contracting authority’s own web page) to submit its offer.
In contrast, the Request for quotations and Single-source direct purchase are considered Non-Competitive because the Invitation to participate is sent by the contracting authority only to specially identified companies.
With all due respect for the Restricted tender, it is still under the attention of specialists as a subject of debate as to whether or not it is a competitive method or procedure, because the Invitation to participate is addressed to a limited number of suppliers, service providers or contractors.
I recall the procedures described in national legislation for information only (we will debate this subject in future issues – which is not so; it is a nicely wrapped hook to get you involved and make you want to keep reading the Revista de Achiziții Publice – RAP), namely:
- Open procedure (LD)
- Restricted procedure (LR)
- Competitive negotiation (NC)
- Competitive dialogue (DC)
- Innovation partnership (PI)
- Negotiation without prior publication (NFP)
- Design contest (CS)
- The award procedure applicable to social and other specific services;
- Simplified procedure (PS)
Competitive Methods
The Open tender, the Request for Proposals (RfP) and the Two-stage tender will be considered competitive methods.
The Open tender is the preferred competitive method and involves set rules and standards for tendering.
It is initiated by the Contract Notice.
The main requirements are:
- Clear and neutral technical specifications
- A procedure open to all qualifiediv participants
- Objective qualification criteria
- National or international advertisingv
- Clear and objective evaluation criteria
- Award to the least costlyvi tenderer without contract negotiation
It is the best-known and most widely used procedure, originally intended for the procurement of products and goods; nevertheless, it may not be the most suitable for complex procurement, where attention is directed more at the results and expectations of the contracting process than strictly at the standards of the procedure itself.
Focusing on the lowest price usually does not take into account the life cycle of the products, services and works and can lead (if these aspects are not clearly defined in the Specifications – CS) to a higher total cost because of the expenses for technical support after the contract is concluded, maintenance, etc. However, a higher price does not automatically mean that there will be no additional costs.
Disadvantages
- long time needed to run the procedure
- requires strict compliance with the rules
- lack of an in-house structure for drawing up technical specifications
- focus on the easiest and least costly solutions
- suppression of innovation
- excessive formalism that may limit competition
- restriction of participation because of the technical specifications
The Request for Proposals (RfP) is the method used when suppliers, service providers or contractors are expected to offer a specific solution (methodology, way of working) to meet the Buyer’s specific requirements.
Tenderers will put their technical and financial offers in separate “envelopes”; the technical proposal is evaluated first against the requirements of the evaluation criteria, and only the financial offers of those economic operators that have fully met the technical requirements will be considered in the next evaluation stage.
The RfP differs from the OT in 6 fundamental activities:
1. Offers are packed in two sealed “envelopes”.
2. At the opening session, the financial proposals are left unopened and guarded (they remain encrypted).
3. The financial proposals are opened publicly and officially only after the evaluation of the technical proposals has been completed.
4. Only the financial proposals of those economic operators that have fully met the technical requirements, as requested, are opened.
5. Selection is made not only on price but also on the proposed solution; and
6. The combined sum of the technical scores and those for the financial proposal will determine the winning tenderer, with whom the contract will be negotiated.
Below are the main differences in the application of the RfP that may cause confusion in applying this method. Thus, in accordance with the public procurement guidelines of the most important Banks: World Bank (http://tinyurl.com/wbprocurement), Asian Development Bank (http://tinyurl.com/adbprocurement), African Development Bank (http://tinyurl.com/afdbprocurement), the RfP is used mainly for hiring consulting firms.
But the Two-stage tender, technically also a kind of Request for Proposals (RfP), as I will explain below, is a method for procuring goods, the execution of works and (non-consulting) services. The procurement manuals of countries such as Ghana (http://www.ppaghana.org/documents/FINALMANUAL_PPB.pdf?story_id=23), Kenya (http://tinyurl.com/kenyagpm) and Rwanda (http://tinyurl.com/Rwandappguide), for example, indicate the use of the Request for Proposals (RfP) for the selection of consulting firms in particular.
Here is an example of 4 selection criteria used for this purpose:
- Quality – price
- Quality
- Fixed budget
- Least costly
In addition, UNCITRAL, in the UNCITRAL Model Law on Public Procurement, identifies three types of Request for Proposals (RfP): (i) without negotiation (Art. 47), (ii) with dialogue (Art. 48), (iii) with consecutive negotiations (Art. 50). However, there are 4 (four) characteristics essential to any Request for Proposals (RfP) method, namely:
1. Sealed proposals (technical and financial) received in response to a Request for Proposals.
2. The technical proposals are opened and evaluated before the financial ones are opened.
3. Only the financial proposals of tenderers whose technical proposals received a minimum eligible score are opened publicly.
4. The final contract is awarded on the basis of the highest score obtained by applying the evaluation criteria as combined scores for the technical proposal and for price, rather than on the lowest price, except in the cases of selection by: quality, fixed budget, least-cost procedure.
The Two-stage tender is similar to the Request for Proposals (RfP), the technical and financial proposals being submitted one after the other rather than simultaneously. It is used for products and services as well as for works.
A key advantage of this method is that
- tendering takes place in two stages, phases; and
- tenderers can help define the technical solutions for the contracting authority’s needs and the scope of the contract.
Here and now, we will discuss only the advantages and disadvantages of this method, given the variety and complexity of its use.
Advantages
1. It offers flexibility in awarding the contract, given that tenderers can take part in drawing up the technical criteria and in adjusting the scope of the contract
2. Economic operators may have a better understanding of the technical requirements and solutions than the contracting authority (entity), so the risk of implementing the project is reduced to the maximum
3. Potential tenderers are able to improve the technical requirements in line with the purpose of performing the contract through the related clarification discussions
4. The time for the second stage is extremely short
5. The methodology for approaching technical solutions can be adjusted so that it is as suitable as possible for the purpose of the work in question
6. Given the involvement of interested economic operators in defining the technical aspects of the scope of the work, the risk of having no tenderers is almost zero
7. A financial proposal is submitted to the Buyer only after the technical requirements and approvals have been met
8. The contract is negotiated on the basis of accepted technical requirements and approvals
9. There is certainty regarding the tenderers’ capacity to perform the contract
Disadvantages
1. Longer time to completion because of the two stages
2. The second stage of negotiation with the technically best-ranked tenderer can be difficult and may take an extremely long time
3. The risk of price escalation in the second stage
4. Once the firm is selected for negotiation, the spirit of competition is lost, which may have a major impact on the price
Non-Competitive Methods
The following non-competitive methods will be highlighted below: the restricted (restrictive) tender, the request for quotations (3 offers), and direct purchase (single source).
The Restricted (restrictive) tender is the method that limits the number of tenderers to a selected number, either because there is only a limited number of potential tenderers able to meet the Buyer’s requirements, or because there are extremely specific conditions limiting the number of participants in order to reduce the time and cost of the selection procedure.
The procedure must take place by setting a number of extremely precise parameters that clearly indicate the number and type of firms that will be able to submit their offers, and this in accordance with the specific public procurement rules.
The Request for quotations is the method used for low-value contracts, for products and goods that are already ready to be purchased, the execution of low-value works, and the provision of services, also of low valuevii.
It is non-competitive because the purchasing legal entity has the right to invite and select certain economic operators (by custom, the accepted number is 3) on the basis of internal criteria.
The request can be made verbally (necessarily with subsequent written confirmation), by e-mail, fax or courier.
Care must be taken not to split these contracts artificially so as to avoid following a procedure, by breaching the threshold for those procedures through reduced values.
Advantages
- A very short time to make the purchase, no advertising obligations and no need to prepare a procurement file. Even the economic operators’ response time is extremely short
- The number of responses is limited to those to whom the Invitation was sent, so the selection time is reduced accordingly
- Purchasers usually know exactly where and from whom they want to buy the products, services or works in question, so there is maximum probability of receiving a satisfactory response
Disadvantages
- Because the Purchaser decides to whom the Request for quotations is sent, there may be suspicions of negligence, fraud, etc.
- There is the possibility of artificially splitting Contracts in order to avoid applying the complex procedures corresponding to their value threshold
- Using this method can very easily lead to the Request being addressed repeatedly only to certain economic operators, although there is a very wide variety of potential suppliers of products, service providers and works contractors
Direct purchase (single source) is certainly a non-competitive method and may be used in clearly defined circumstances, namely:
- emergency situations
- when there is only one firm that can perform the contract
- for the continuation of works or the purchase of new ones that can only be awarded to the same contractor for reasons of technical compatibility, the existence of a patent or of intellectual property rights
- when using this method brings a clear and indisputable advantage to the Buyer compared with the other procedures
- when the purchase of certain goods is accessible only from a particular source
- in other situations provided for in the legislation in the field applicable to the Purchaser
The use of this method must be preceded by a rigorous justification within a process, a previously approved procedure.
The justifications must clearly identify:
- the purchaser
- the description of the purchase
- the justification note on why this purchase can be made only from the cited source
- the actions taken to identify other potential tenderers too
- the total cost of the purchase
- the actions planned to prevent such situations of needing to purchase from a single source
Preparation requires time and expertise
In some cases, preparation may take a long time, but it is always a crucial stage.
Depending on the size and complexity of the contract, preparation could take a few days or even a few months before the contract notice is ready for publication. However, good planning should minimise the risk of having to modify or vary a contract during its performance and can help avoid errors.
Figure 1. The stages of a typical public procurement procedure
| 1. Preparation and planning | 2. Publication and transparency | 3. Submission of tenders and selection of tenderers | 4. Evaluation and award | 5. Contract performance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| • Detecting the future need • Involving stakeholders • Market analysis • Defining the subject matter • Choosing the procedure | • Drafting the specifications, including the criteria • Preparing the procurement documents • Advertising the contract • Providing clarifications | • Receiving and opening the tenders • Applying the exclusion grounds • Selecting suitable tenderers | • Evaluating the tenders • Awarding and signing the contract • Notifying tenderers and publication | • Managing and monitoring performance • Making payments • If necessary, modifying or terminating the contract • Closing the contract |
Indeed, in the context of ESI Funds financing, numerous analyses aimed at establishing the cause of malfunctions have concluded that poor planning, especially at the beginning of the procurement process, was the cause of the biggest errors.
Consequently, contracting authorities are increasingly employing specialised public procurement officers, especially when carrying out complex, risky and high-value public procurement.
This increased professionalisation of the public procurement function is considered best practice.
Sources:
Procurement Method Selection, by Jorge A. Lynch T.
Implementing the EU Directives on the selection of economic operators in public procurement procedures, Lemke, M. et al. (2018), SIGMA Papers, No. 56, OECD Publishing, Paris: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/f511e46f-en
European Commission, DG GROW: https://ec.europa.eu/growth/single-market/public-procurement_ro
Public procurement guidance for practitioners on avoiding the most common errors in projects funded by the European Structural and Investment Funds: http://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/en/policy/how/improving-investment/public-procurement/guide/
Prof. Gabriela ILIN
Public Procurement Specialist and Expert
Dipl. Eng. Ovidiu SLIMAC
Public Procurement Specialist and Expert
Notes
- i To be read as: both novices in the field and masters (those with seven years’ experience or more in the field) ↩
- ii United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, UNCITRAL: http://www.uncitral.org/uncitral/uncitral_texts/procurement_infrastructure/2011Model.html ↩
- iii SICAP – the electronic public procurement system in Romania ↩
- iv To be read as: capable ↩
- v Official Journal of the European Union, TED (Tenders Electronic Daily): https://ted.europa.eu/TED/main/HomePage.do ↩
- vi Whatever award criterion is used ↩
- vii In Romanian legislation, it resembles those direct purchases for works and services that are more complex than buying on the basis of an invoice and packing up products ready to be taken to the premises of the contracting authority (entity) ↩
Reference
Ilin, G., & Slimac, O. (2018). Clădește-ți o carieră de succes în achiziții [Build a successful career in procurement].
Editorial note
Published materials express the opinions and analyses of the authors who sign them and do not necessarily represent the position of Achiziții Corecte / Correct Procurement. Each author is responsible, in accordance with the law, for the content of their own contribution, including the statements made, the accuracy of information, the identification of sources, and respect for third-party rights. Publishing or making a material available does not constitute adoption or validation of all its opinions and conclusions. The materials are for information purposes and do not replace advice tailored to a particular situation. This note does not exclude liabilities that cannot be excluded by law.