← Academia · Versiunea în română
Translated from Romanian by Achiziții Corecte. The Romanian text is the reference version.
The 5 Cs
I have said it, written it and debated it before:
- As long as we obtain the right price, in the right quantity, at the right time, at the right quality, in the right place and from the right source, we are technically managing correct procurement.
What is that Principle which is not enshrined by the legislator but which we all aim for?
The Principle of Correctness!
The 5 Cs
- The CORRECT Quality
- The CORRECT Quantity
- The CORRECT Place
- The CORRECT Time
- The CORRECT Price
As you know, abuse of office has been redefined with a threshold set at the level of the gross minimum wage, and it is considered abuse of office if the purpose is to obtain undue benefits for oneself, one’s spouse or relatives up to the second degree.
Whether we call them principles, correct ones, whether we name them key indicators (we too have become “anglicised”) or even essential factors of procurement, what matters is that we do not let ourselves be diverted from them, from the principles, and that we pursue their implementation, the implementation of the 5 Cs.
Which reminds me of the “3 Rs”, now called the Circular Economy, and in Timișoara, at the beginning of this year 2018, on 17 – 19 January, and I must point this out, the First International Forum of the ROVEST Cluster took place, organised in partnership with the West University of Timișoara, with prestigious international participation and dedicated to procurement.
The speakers were: Mr Bogdan Pușcaș – President, National Agency for Public Procurement (ANAP), Mr Dumitru Viorel Pârvu – Complaints Adjudication Counsellor, National Council for Solving Complaints (CNSC), Mr Liviu Dominic Dumitru – Procurement Expert, Mr Alin Izvoran, Procurement Expert, Transelectrica, Ms Gabriela Ilin – President, ROVEST Cluster, Ms Christina Leucuța – Senior Adviser, CLUSTERO, Mr Cristian Găină – EU Funds Expert, Mr Cosmin Șerbănescu – President, National Institute of Internal Control of Romania (INCIR), Mr Gabriel Zaharia – Evaluator, Ovidiu Slimac – Procurement Expert, from Romania.
Mr Emmanuel Morel – Expert, European Investment Bank, Mr Robin Jackson – CEO, ADR International, UK, Mr Ioan Baciu – Procurement Expert, EU Stakeholder, Mr Rajiv Gupta – Founder, Procurement League, USA, Mr Alexander E. Mok – PhD in Public Procurement, Netherlands, Mr Joan Prummel – Strategic Adviser Circular Procurement, Netherlands.
Here and now the concept of Circular Procurement was introduced in Romania for the first time, alongside the definition of the idea of the “Circular Economy”, which, I would say, is a concept “invented” in the Romania of the ’75s, applied by an entire nation, and we are not discussing the political regime of that time but only the beneficial effects of the “3 Rs”: Recycling, Reusing, Reconditioning!
Let us note that from this July, of the year 2018, the Circular Economy Package, “The EU’s Circular Economy Package”, will become law at European Union level, which will mean that new and ambitious targets will be set for recycling waste from towns and cities, with the specific objective of packaging and separating bio waste and waste destined for the “ecological landfill”. At the same time, Member States will have a set of rules for collecting textile waste separately from household waste.
Idea worth remembering:
The Circular Economy Club offers a free mentoring placement to start-up experts, students and young entrepreneurs. Anyone interested can follow this link: https://lnkd.in/ePq8VzM
The CORRECT Quality
It is obtained when we procure (the products, services, works (P, S, W) exactly suited to the needs of the contracting authority (the buyer), through the desired, required and obtained quality standard, through accurate fulfilment of the requested technical specifications and through quality management.
It is NOT obtained when:
- The stock does not meet the quality requirements
- The products have manufacturing defects (more or less visible) that require them to be reworked or replaced with new ones
- Defective products that have reached the end consumer require a recall to production (essentially, withdrawal of the entire batch), compensation, complaints, loss of credibility
- The manufacturer faces extremely large cost increases
The CORRECT Quantity
It is obtained when products are delivered in sufficient quantities, minimising the unnatural growth of stocks, which entails costs and risks for the contracting authority, through a judicious analysis of the Inventory, of the stock replenishment system and of correct forecasts.
If it is NOT obtained, then:
- Stock may be insufficient
- Production will stall, which entails unforeseen additional costs, delays in delivering products, loss of credibility, of market and of sales
- Stock will be excessive, which will lead to tied-up capital, loss of storage capacity, risk of damage to the goods, risk of non-use and of going out of fashion, additional storage costs
The CORRECT Place
It is obtained when the purchased products are delivered to the desired place, not elsewhere, packed and transported in such a way that they arrive in the best condition, without any transport or handling damage, through correct planning of the distribution of goods, of transport and of packaging.
If it is NOT obtained, then:
- Delivery delays and unplanned costs will arise because of the unsuitable place of delivery
- The goods will become more expensive through the associated handling and transport costs
- The products may be stolen, damaged or contaminated during this whole prolonged transit, which may also cause environmental contamination
The CORRECT Time
It is obtained when the products arrive at the specified time at the planned place, not too early, so as not to increase storage and inventory costs.
It is NOT obtained when:
- The products are delivered too late, causing associated late-delivery costs, additional costs for repairing damage, loss of business
- The products are delivered too early and thus storage, handling and inventory costs will increase
The CORRECT Price
It is obtained when we procure (the products, services, works (P, S, W) at a competitive price, reasonable in relation to the buyer’s request, fair and in accordance with transparent procedures, by lowering procurement costs and increasing profit (and I leave you the pleasure of discovering it within contracting authorities/entities), through analysis according to the evaluation factors, of the price, the art of correct negotiation.
If it is NOT obtained, then:
- Suppliers will feel free to charge as much as they like without feeling that they are being checked
- Suppliers’ profit margins may be squeezed and they may feel insecure under this contract
- The cost of materials and of supply will rise unjustifiably
- Profit may fall – or the price charged to the buyer may rise, which may lead to lost sales
However, this analysis would be inconceivable and quite pointless if we did not also take into account the correct supplier, service provider or contractor, who is in fact the essential party (playing the primary role) in achieving the objectives of the procurement in question.
The phrase up for debate could then be:
As long as we obtain the right price, in the right quantity, at the right time, at the right quality, in the right place and from the right source, we are technically managing correct procurement. ?
Of course, because one may also take into account the potential for innovation and research & development, and the partner’s willingness to take part in circular, innovative, green procurement, in an ethical environment with high energy performance and environmental protection.
Prof. Gabriela ILIN
Public Procurement Specialist and Expert
Dipl. Eng. Ovidiu SLIMAC
Public Procurement Specialist and Expert
Reference
Ilin, G., & Slimac, O. (2018, July). Principiul Achizițiilor Corecte – Cei 5 C [The Principle of Correct Procurement – The 5 Cs]. Revista de Achiziții Publice, (130).
Editorial note
Published materials express the opinions and analyses of the authors who sign them and do not necessarily represent the position of Achiziții Corecte / Correct Procurement. Each author is responsible, in accordance with the law, for the content of their own contribution, including the statements made, the accuracy of information, the identification of sources, and respect for third-party rights. Publishing or making a material available does not constitute adoption or validation of all its opinions and conclusions. The materials are for information purposes and do not replace advice tailored to a particular situation. This note does not exclude liabilities that cannot be excluded by law.