Simplifying Public Procurement – Wish or Active Necessity

← Academia · Versiunea în română

Translated from Romanian by Achiziții Corecte. The Romanian text is the reference version.

Wish or Active Necessity

Declared objectives: the health, morale and standard of living (well-being) of the citizen.

  • In the interest of public policy, the legislature and the judiciary will annul any action or contract that runs counter to these objectives, even if its being declared without legal effect is not expressly provided for.
  • When deciding public policy, the politician must think about the effects on the heart, since it is the most affected.

After 15+ years of activity in (public) procurement, a very long time, with hair turning grey in places, I can compare myself to the dinosaurs – the extinction of the procurement phenomenon as we know it is knocking at the door.

The asteroid being replaced by the internet age, by the speed at which technologies change:

  • even in medicine, operating techniques are becoming more and more technical, with a robot able to carry out various surgical procedures instead of a human being; are you, too, about to disappear?
  • We must embrace e-procurement, which some 15 – 20 years ago did not even exist
  • You see that it is still possible to negotiate (within the limits laid down by legislation, but anyway … the possibility exists) legally, without entering into any conflict of interest!

Savings – should become a result, not a goal!

  • E-procurement – e-commerce: purchases can be made by card, on the basis of an e-mail, and there are certainly employees (some inept) who think only about achieving their own objectives.
  • We must have a system that they know!
  • End users now want the best – procurement staff may fall into the sin of steering towards the product that “the bosses” want to buy, with the simplistic reasoning: “they say it is cheaper there”.

The procurement adviser must be on an equal footing with the finance and legal staff in terms of freedom and independence, think about it a little!

How do we get past the stupid edict: no “order note”, no payment?

  • Mobility is an important concept – yet order notes by phone can be disastrous:
  • I didn’t know you were asking me
  • I cannot take a decision
  • I didn’t have time to look over every approved request
  • Now it is tomorrow, so it is already too late
  • So it would be highly advisable to have: automated validations

What other name would procurement have?

  • (External) Resource Management
  • In some entities, procurement does not play a decisive role in the organisation; it is always under someone, even though procurement advisers would be the special forces, not the regular troops of the institution’s arsenal, bringing significant value to reducing the entity’s costs; what is more (it might be funny if it were not true), sometimes even the name is taken pejoratively: bring me this, that, get hold of the other thing, etc.
  • We, Procurement, collaborate with suppliers, we do not “manage” them!
  • KPI
  • The usefulness of procurement; the question arises: how much should we spend?
  • These indicators must also be measured at suppliers
  • Where could we have saved more, and how, and why?

We ask ourselves questions

1. What is your role in the procurement process?

i. Involved in determining needs, defining expected results and securing the budget needed to achieve these objectives. Decision based on the support of those in the specialised department to achieve the best value, through ethics and transparency.

Tip: Implement and review the internal procurement policy to confirm authority in the contracting process (delegation of powers).

2. Ethics – let us stay on the right path

i. Declaration of any conflict of interest; rely on the procurement adviser to guide you in this respect. Recuse yourself as soon as you consider yourself to be in a conflict of interest.

Tip: Ethical behaviour is based on procurement principles in connection with any process, relationships and actions linked to public procurement procedures. Avoid any favouritism.

3. Authority in procurement – how important is it?

i. It is most appropriate for all procurement processes to be placed at the disposal of the Head (of the department, office, unit), a Procurement Adviser who has sufficient independence in decision-making and a high level of knowledge in the field, through participation in courses, seminars and conferences in the field that have given them Competences in procurement.

ii. There is the legal possibility of outsourcing your procurement services, partly or entirely, so you can have CPOs for different activities: construction, IT, etc.

iii. You can create Partnerships with other entities and carry out centralised procurement, by delegating the procurement process to another (contracting) authority.

Tip: The structure of the Organisation Chart must clearly highlight the independence of “Procurement”, on the same level as “Finance”, “Legal”, etc.

4. What value does “Procurement” bring to the contracting authority?

i. As a mature profession (our proposal, that of SN SEAP, is for it to become a – liberal profession), sophisticated and with a wide range of activities, if allowed, it will bring real benefits to the entity, being also one of the most visible departments, through the correct implementation of the Unit’s Strategic Plan.

ii. An intelligent leader, like you, will give this important office all the means for awareness and risk reduction by maintaining integrity throughout the unit. In this increasingly complex world you can no longer afford a dinosaur-type model – ancient and outdated thinking in procurement; otherwise you will find extinction knocking at the door like an asteroid.

Tip: Also accept the contribution, as that of a personal adviser, of the “Head of Procurement” to the discussions of the Management Committee, in order to optimise the strategic and operational decision-making of your unit.

5. Values and Principles in procurement

i. Transparency, impartiality, economy, professionalism, etc., which you must know how to apply internally. They will also determine how you are treated by contractors and tenderers, and will affect the way other government partners treat you. Be in the media, in the news, for your excellent results, not for mistakes.

Tip: Ask procurement professionals to make sure that the contracting authority you lead develops progressively across the wide range of procurement.

6. The difference in the procurement process between the public and the private sector

i. Two major differences: Transparency and Complexity

ii. The first: the public sector has a set of clear rules of open competition, equal for all participants (with some exceptions, see negotiation); the private sector is free to choose whatever methods it wishes, transparent or not, competitive or not.

iii. The second: private-sector procurement is simple from the perspective of contributing to the organisation’s profit, with no other social responsibility goal (we are not talking here about the obligations of large companies to implement Social Responsibility systematically. By contrast, public procurement will take into account a multitude of factors: speed, low price, quality conditions, social, health, environmental and occupational safety conditions, transparency.

Tip: The public and private operating systems may seem similar at first sight, but the standards and rules, and the accounting, differ fundamentally. Do not make the mistake of applying private-sector standards to public-sector obligations.

7. Methods in procurement

i. Procurement processes are not simple and do not work on the principle “applies to everyone, any time”. The current trend is to bring innovation into procurement as well (the Innovation Partnership, for example), and to create the most flexible professional and legislative framework possible for selecting the most suitable contractors. Any small error can have major repercussions later in the implementation of contracts.

Tip: Seek to have procurement professionals, specialists recognised (by other experts) and with competences (not necessarily diplomas), capable of taking the best decisions for the benefit of your unit.

8. Emergencies

i. They are your core responsibilities!

ii. The procurement adviser can help you through the logistical support needed for recovery after natural disasters, floods, earthquakes, epidemics.

Tip: Involve procurement advisers in the strategic and operational plans of your entity.

9. Outsourcing

i. Is using the private sector to provide services, or outsourcing them completely, a good idea? Public-Private Partnership or partial or total Outsourcing may be considered a controversial issue, but it can be the smart choice in certain circumstances. Any decision must be taken after demonstrating the value, the gain for the public sector.

Tip: Procurement specialists (if there are any) should also be consulted, as they have the tools and skills needed for such an analysis.

10. Social policies and contractual preferences

i. Access to public contracts must be as easy as possible for the widest possible range of economic operators, including sheltered workshops. For example, public procurement will be a catalyst for social and economic sustainability precisely by granting access to these sheltered units.

Tip: When deciding on the access of sheltered units, consulting the procurement adviser is essential to prevent possible design errors.

Prof. Gabriela ILIN
Public Procurement Specialist and Expert

Dipl. Eng. Ovidiu SLIMAC
Public Procurement Specialist and Expert

Reference

Ilin, G., & Slimac, O. (n.d.). Simplificarea Achizițiilor Publice – Dorință sau Necesitate Activă [Simplifying Public Procurement – Wish or Active Necessity].

Editorial note

Published materials express the opinions and analyses of the authors who sign them and do not necessarily represent the position of Achiziții Corecte / Correct Procurement. Each author is responsible, in accordance with the law, for the content of their own contribution, including the statements made, the accuracy of information, the identification of sources, and respect for third-party rights. Publishing or making a material available does not constitute adoption or validation of all its opinions and conclusions. The materials are for information purposes and do not replace advice tailored to a particular situation. This note does not exclude liabilities that cannot be excluded by law.