Reading 2 – Essential principles in procurement?

← Academia · Versiunea în română

Translated from Romanian by Achiziții Corecte. The Romanian text is the reference version.

I have been there, I needed help. I am here. I offer help.

Lesson 2 – Essential Principles in Procurement?

Lesson 2. The essential principles of public procurement

Introduction

There are many definitions of the word “principle”, but the most precise definition relating to public procurement is the one given by BusinessDictionary.com, which defines “principles1” as “Fundamental norms, rules, or values that represent what is desirable and positive for a person, group, organization, or community, and help it in determining the rightfulness or wrongfulness of its actions. Principles are more basic than policy and objectives, and are meant to govern both.”

Principles are the foundation of public procurement. Principles govern the management of public procurement and set the framework for rules and a code of conduct for public procurement practitioners and other officials involved directly or indirectly in this process.

As a public procurement practitioner, expert or specialist, you must have a clear understanding of the principles of public procurement and know how to apply them to guide your public procurement decisions. By integrating these principles into your work ethic, the outcomes of your decisions will always be consistent with the purpose of public procurement.

As a practitioner employed in public procurement, you are a public official. You administer public funds, you are bound by an ethical code of conduct and you are accountable for what you do or fail to do when managing these funds.

What are some of the basic principles of public procurement?

Some of the basic principles of public procurement are transparency, integrity, economy, openness, fairness, competition and accountability. Each of these is explained below.

Transparency in public procurement is important because information on the public procurement process must be made available to all interested parties: contractors, suppliers, service providers and the general public, unless there are valid and legal reasons for not disclosing certain information. Examples of confidential information are the intellectual property information of companies or persons taking part in the procurement process, as well as certain military and national defence procurements.

When a public procurement requirement is advertised electronically, through a press release, on the internet or elsewhere, the notice must include sufficient detail for interested contractors, suppliers and service providers to understand it easily and determine whether they are qualified to compete. Tender documents, in particular, must be available free of charge or, if not, at a reasonable price.

After reading the tender documents, interested contractors, suppliers and service providers should be able to establish:

  • the nature of the requirement and its scope;
  • The deadline for submitting tenders and for requesting information
  • The evaluation and selection criteria
  • How and where tenders must be submitted
  • The number of copies to be sent and the contact point for further information and answers to questions (clarifications)
  • The deadline for requesting clarification
  • The schedule of pre-procedure meetings and site visits (if applicable) and any other relevant details

If the solicitation documents are amended, all interested parties should be notified using the same means as were used for the initial notification, so that interested contractors, suppliers or service providers are informed and able to take the necessary measures in good time to comply with the change.

In essence, clarity and access to information are essential aspects of transparency in public procurement.

Integrity

According to the OECD procurement2 toolbox, “Integrity”:

can be defined as the use of funds, resources, assets and authority according to the intended official purposes, to be used in line with the public interest.

In the context of public procurement, this implies that

(i) public procurement procedures are transparent and promote fair and equal treatment of suppliers / tenderers;

(ii) the conduct of procurement practitioners is in line with the public purpose of their organisation; and

(iii) systems are in place to check procurement decisions, ensure accountability and promote public scrutiny.

From the definition above, two main aspects of integrity can be considered the most important:

1) the integrity of the public procurement process, which includes the use of funds, procurement procedures and systems, and

2) the integrity of the procurement practitioners who are tasked with overseeing and carrying out the procurement process.

Integrity of the procurement process

The integrity of the procurement process ensures trust in the public procurement system. Integrity is, in essence, reliable. Tenderers must be able to rely on any information provided by the contracting entity, formally or informally. When tender documents are made public, the information they contain must be reliable and free of ambiguity or bias.

When examining the solicitation documents, potential tenderers should be able to establish the qualification requirements and know, understand and trust how these will be evaluated. The evaluation and selection criteria must be clearly stated in the tender documents and should remain unchanged unless they need to be amended. If an amendment is necessary, the tender documents must be amended, published and made available to all potential tenderers. Any change to the tender submission date should allow tenderers enough time to adjust their tender accordingly to meet the new submission deadline.

Integrity of public procurement practitioners

Practitioners, specialists and experts working within procuring entities and other government officials involved in the public procurement process must embody personal and professional integrity. Ideally, there should be no discrepancy between personal and professional integrity.

All public officials involved directly and indirectly in the public procurement process should at all times be perceived as honest, credible, responsible and reliable. They must always keep in mind the objective of the public procurement requirement and strive to ensure that they manage public procurement responsibly in accordance with the public procurement rules.

Economy

Synonymous with efficiency, value for money and a commercially reasonable price, the principle of economy stresses the need to manage public funds carefully and diligently, so that the prices paid for goods, services and works are acceptable and represent good value for the public funds spent on these purchases.

Any person associated with the public procurement process or directly responsible for facilitating the purchase of goods and services with public funds should strive to avoid fraud, wasteful spending and abuse of public resources – whether as a result of overestimating the Estimated value of the goods required -, to avoid accepting high prices for goods that do not meet standards, and to avoid3 collusion with tenderers or other forms of unacceptable practice.

Openness

Public procurement requirements should be open to all qualified organisations and individuals. The public should also have access to information relating to public procurement, but access to such information is not absolute. Confidential and intellectual property information, or information of another legal nature, belonging to organisations and persons taking part in the process should not be publicly available, and the extent of its disclosure is detailed in the public procurement rules or in other relevant regulations.

There are also procurement methods, such as restricted or selective tendering, which limit the availability of tender documents to firms meeting certain qualifications. Requests for quotations (e.g. for purchases below the legislative threshold for procedures) and direct contracting (from a single source) also impose certain limitations on competition, because the invitation to submit a price quotation is limited to a certain number and type of organisations or individuals.

The evaluation of tenders received must be kept confidential until the evaluation group reaches a final conclusion and after the evaluation report has been cleared by a designated approving authority, such as the tender or bid evaluation committee. Most national defence procurement is confidential, limiting relevant information to a “need to know” basis.

Except for confidential defence procurement, the results of the public procurement process should be published and made available on the relevant websites, http://sicap-prod.e-licitatie.ro/pub, as well as on those of the contracting authority / entity itself. In addition, public procurement information (except confidential / intellectual property information, etc.) should be made available to everyone, even if on the basis of restricted access, in accordance with the rules already established for public procurement, in this context.

Fairness

Fairness has different meanings depending on how it is used. In public procurement, we might simply say that fairness means treating all tenderers equally, but it is not that simple. Below are some examples of how fairness is applied in public procurement.

To achieve fairness in the public procurement process:

  • Decisions and actions must be impartial and no preferential treatment should be extended to any person or organisation, given that public procurement activities are carried out with public funds.
  • All tenders must be considered on the basis of their compliance with the provisions of the tender documents, and tenders must not be rejected for reasons other than those specified in the tender documents and in the procurement rules.
  • A contract must be awarded only to the supplier, contractor or service provider whose tender is compliant and best meets the objectives of the requirement in terms of technical capacity and price.
  • Suppliers, contractors or service providers should have the right to challenge the procurement process whenever they consider that they have been treated unfairly or that the contracting entity has failed to carry out the procurement process in accordance with the procurement rules. These challenges must be based on the tender documents and / or the procurement rules.

Competition

The public procurement process must not be manipulated for the benefit of any organisation or person. Since public procurement is financed mainly from taxpayers’ money, all eligible organisations and individuals should have the right to take part by submitting a tender in response to a specific requirement for which they are qualified.

Public procurement requirements should be widely advertised to increase the chances of a good market response, which would lead to contracts being awarded at reasonable prices.

Michael Asner considers that “fair and open competition is the backbone of public procurement”. Nevertheless, not all contracts are awarded through a competitive process, as this sometimes depends on the urgency of the need and on the resulting procurement method used to meet a particular specific requirement.

The use of non-competitive procurement methods, although justified under certain conditions, should be kept to a minimum. Examples of non-competitive procurement methods include shopping (also called, under certain conditions, requests for quotations or invitations to quote) and direct contracting (single / exclusive source supply). Each of these non-competitive procurement methods has its purpose and should not be used abusively.

Accountability

Accountability in public procurement should be understood to mean that every person involved in the public procurement process is responsible for their actions and decisions.

As public officials, public procurement practitioners and others involved directly and indirectly in the public procurement process are accountable and exposed to sanctions for any conduct that breaches the public procurement rules. They are also obliged to report and / or answer to a designated oversight entity and to the public regarding the consequences of their actions and decisions.

The principle of the 5 Cs

The Principle of Correct Procurement – The 5 Cs

I have said it, written it and debated it before:

  • As long as we obtain the right price, in the right quantity, at the right time, at the right quality, in the right place and from the right source, we are technically managing correct procurement.

What is that Principle which is not enshrined by the legislator but which we all aim for?

The Principle of Correctness!

The 5 Cs

  • The CORRECT Quality
  • The CORRECT Quantity
  • The CORRECT Place
  • The CORRECT Time
  • The CORRECT Price

The purpose of contract administration is to provide adequate mechanisms for monitoring and evaluating the performance of contractors, suppliers and service providers in fulfilling their contractual obligations, and to ensure that appropriate action is taken to remedy promptly any deficiencies found in the performance of the contract or in the scope of the contract, as well as in the contractual terms and conditions.

On the basis of their specific objectives, there is a clear distinction between public procurement and contract administration. This distinction, far from diminishing the importance of one as opposed to the other, truly strengthens each, by identifying and focusing on the specific purpose of each.

Prof. Gabriela ILIN
Public Procurement Specialist and Expert

Dipl. Eng. Ovidiu SLIMAC
Public Procurement Specialist and Expert

Notes

References

Ilin, G., & Slimac, O. (2019a). Lectura 2 – Principii esențiale în achiziții? [Reading 2 – Essential principles in procurement?]. Revista de Achiziții Publice, (142), 14–15.

Ilin, G., & Slimac, O. (2019b). Lectura 2 – Principii esențiale în achiziții? [Continuare] [Reading 2 – Essential principles in procurement? (Continued)]. Revista de Achiziții Publice, (143), 15–17.

Editorial note

Published materials express the opinions and analyses of the authors who sign them and do not necessarily represent the position of Achiziții Corecte / Correct Procurement. Each author is responsible, in accordance with the law, for the content of their own contribution, including the statements made, the accuracy of information, the identification of sources, and respect for third-party rights. Publishing or making a material available does not constitute adoption or validation of all its opinions and conclusions. The materials are for information purposes and do not replace advice tailored to a particular situation. This note does not exclude liabilities that cannot be excluded by law.