Reading 1 – What is public procurement?

← Academia · Versiunea în română

Translated from Romanian by Achiziții Corecte. The Romanian text is the reference version.

I have been there, I needed help. I am here. I offer help.

Lesson 1 – What is public procurement?

Many procurement practitioners have not paid much attention to this question, which is essential for gaining a better understanding of our profession. Most of us start getting involved in the procurement process simply by doing it. We may be lucky enough to be guided by a senior practitioner; we are told to read a public procurement manual, the legislation, since there is only one Law1 (for classic procurement), then we are told to get on with it and we are given work2.

We may start by using tender documents by filling in templates (that is, we look at what our predecessors have done in the matter and try to remember on which of those wonderful 5 days spent on the Romanian seaside we read about it, at the course that relieved us of some stress, and not only that, we also received an A.N.C.-accredited diploma, issued by a firm accredited by the same people or by others, which no longer matters to you, the diploma that gives you the status of “procurement expert”) and you are told to fill in only the blank spaces (or those not common to the template in question), and so we will progress accordingly until we fill in the gaps in the template by ourselves. And so we believe we are doing ‘public procurement’, and we may even call ourselves ‘public procurement advisers (CAP)’, without thinking much about what public procurement represents.

But our lack of understanding is not entirely our fault because, as you will read in the paper entitled “What is public procurement? Definitional problems and implications” by Robert E. Lloyd and Clifford P. McCue, “there are inconsistencies regarding the body of knowledge and the terminology used to define public procurement. Perspectives on what public procurement is or should be range from the routine of filling in the ‘gaps’ to a sophisticated analysis of the spending of contracting authorities3.”

Thus, for the purposes of this e-Course, public procurement is defined as the purchase of goods, services and construction works to support the operations of contracting authorities3 and to provide public goods and services. These services include: public transport and municipal services, medical and educational facilities and services, roads, bridges and other public infrastructure, as well as other public services.

The main reason why procurement is “public” is that all the goods, services and construction works referred to are purchased with funds obtained through the payment of taxes and / or the grants and loans given to the country, the government, the ministry, the county council, the local council, the contracting authority3, or the charges paid for public goods and services.

So, once we understand the above, we should take an interest in and know the purpose of public procurement, who its actors, stakeholders and beneficiaries are, and what constitutes the legal basis for public procurement.

The purpose of public procurement

The purpose of public procurement is to award timely and cost-effective contracts to qualified contractors, suppliers and service providers for the provision of goods and services to support the operations of the contracting authority4 and public services, in accordance with the rules, principles and procedures established in the public procurement legislation.

Actors, stakeholders and beneficiaries

Public procurement specialists and experts are the main actors in the public procurement process. They are responsible for ensuring that the objective of public procurement is achieved. To achieve this, they must win the trust of stakeholders, fully understand the procurement process and comply with the public procurement rules.

Public procurement specialists and experts are involved directly and indirectly in the procurement process, from the assessment of needs to the conclusion of the contract; they also support contract administration.

Stakeholders are all those who are to benefit from the results of public procurement, including those interested in the process who might be affected, directly or indirectly, by a particular action or direction in public procurement.

The difference between stakeholders and procurement actors is the degree of their participation in the public procurement process. Stakeholders play a passive role, while actors are directly involved in the public procurement process. Actors are also stakeholders because of the benefits they may have and the interest they should have in the effective provision of public goods and services.

All the inhabitants of a country benefit from the public procurement system through the public goods and services available and offered to them in the form of transport systems, public utilities, educational systems and medical services and facilities, and other soft and hard public infrastructure, among others.

Similarities and differences between public-sector and private-sector procurement

Both public and private procurement are intended to purchase goods and services and, in some cases, infrastructure works. The main difference between these two types of organisation is the purpose of purchasing the goods and services in question. Public-sector procurement focuses mainly on social benefits, while private-sector procurement is largely profit-oriented; their activities are directed primarily at making a profit. In the public sector, the two main reasons for purchasing goods and services are: (i) supporting government operations and (ii) providing public goods and services.

The source of funding is another fundamental difference between public and private procurement. While private-sector procurement is financed by the owners / shareholders of the company, the source of funds for public procurement is primarily based on taxes and charges and / or grants and loans obtained by the government on behalf of the country.

As regards regulatory rules, private-sector procurement mainly follows contract or commercial law as regards the formation of contracts, but procurement methods are governed by company policies, dictated by the company’s objectives. A private company may enter into a contract with another private company or an individual, and the procurement method is dictated entirely by the company’s internal policies.

However, the entire public procurement process is governed by the rules laid down by public procurement legislation – the public legal and institutional framework for procurement – and practitioners are obliged to comply with them. In most countries there is a law regulating the purchase of goods, services and works with public funds. These rules establish the basis for how public procurement must be managed, as well as the various methods permitted in different circumstances.

As regards oversight, the private-sector procurement process is largely closed to public scrutiny. In contrast, public-sector procurement is open to public scrutiny, and public procurement practitioners are accountable for their actions. They must also ensure that public procurement is managed in accordance with the principles and procedures specified in the public procurement rules.

Public procurement must also respect certain principles. The process should be open to public scrutiny, depending on the procurement method used and on any confidentiality agreement arising from it.

Sometimes the public procurement law is very detailed and at other times it covers only the fundamentals, leaving the details for further development in public procurement guidelines and manuals, which should expand on but not contradict the law. The management of public procurement, the identification of requirements and budget allocation, procurement planning and strategy development, the selection of the procurement method, the preparation and advertising of tender documents, the submission of tenders and proposals, evaluation and selection, and the award of contracts through to completion are addressed in the public procurement rules.

Public procurement specialists, experts and practitioners are not allowed to use procurement methods that are not provided for in the public procurement rules or are not identified for a particular type of public procurement requirement. Any deviation from the public procurement rules requires formal justification and authorisation from a designated approving authority, sometimes a tender committee, before acting, unless there is a case of force majeure, an imminent danger to life or a major loss or loss of public resources.

The similarities and differences between public-sector and private-sector procurement are presented in the following table:

Table 1 Similarities and differences between public-sector and private-sector procurement

Public SectorPrivate Sector
Objectives:Purchase of goods, services and worksPurchase of goods and services
Purpose:Society-centric development, not for profit.Profit-centric. The scope is limited to the organisation’s vision, mission and objectives
Source of funding:Public funds (taxes and charges, and loans and grants from bilateral / multilateral financing institutions)Private funds (shareholders, investors and others)
Rules:The procurement legal framework, regulations, instructions and manuals govern the entire process, from the identification of requirements to the conclusion of the contract.Contract (commercial) law governs the formation of a contract, but the procurement method is determined by company policies.
The process:• Open to public scrutiny
• Practitioners are accountable
• Governed by procurement principles as stipulated in the public procurement rules
Closed to public scrutiny, unless an illegal act is suspected
• Governed by company policy
• Open to shareholder scrutiny
Expenditure authorisation:Management is based on the revenue and expenditure budgetManagement
Public procurement specialists, experts, Practitioners:Publicly accountableAccountable only to the company

The legal framework

Public procurement is governed by the public procurement legal framework, which is a law or regulation (or part of a law or regulation) that is sanctioned by the judicial system of a given country. It establishes the basis for managing public procurement.

The public procurement legal framework is generally developed further into policies and procedures, manuals and guidelines on procurement and contract management, including the standard solicitation (tender / bidding) documents used to request offers from qualified tenderers / suppliers.

The legal and institutional framework for public procurement (the public procurement rules) regulates everything, from the identification of a requirement to the conclusion of a contract; sometimes including the disposal, reuse and destruction of goods.

Here are some additional articles that may help you with this topic:

Procurement

Procurement is the process of purchasing goods and services (including civil works) by a public or private entity to satisfy a specific need. Two broad categories of procurement are identified here: goods and services. I consider that these include public procurement of public works, including utilities such as water, sewerage and electricity, given that (at least in public procurement) civil construction works are contracted ultimately to provide a service – a medical facility is built to provide medical services, a school to accommodate pupils in the process of providing educational services, etc. So, whatever infrastructure the government builds, its purpose is to provide public services.

In view of the above, it is important to classify procurement further according to the sector in which it is used, namely: public or private; thus, the following is the classification we will use:

i. Public-sector procurement,

ii. Private-sector procurement and

iii. Project procurement

A. – Public-sector project procurement, and –

b. – Procurement processing in the private sector

Below, the first two (public and private procurement) are defined.

Public-sector procurement

Public procurement is the process of purchasing goods and services for the functioning of government and the provision of public services. It is carried out within a specific legal framework based on certain principles aimed at ensuring that public procurement requirements are fulfilled competitively by qualified firms and individuals, in a transparent and non-discriminatory manner, on the basis of pre-established selection criteria. The purpose of public procurement is to provide everything necessary for the functioning of government and, in particular, of public services for the population of a country.

Private-sector procurement

In contrast, private-sector procurement is the process of purchasing goods and services to meet the needs of a particular private entity (usually a business, for profit or not). These are goods and services needed for:

(i) the functioning of the business or (ii) the business, to be used in the process of producing the goods and / or services it provides to its customers.

In the first case, the primary examples are goods such as stationery, furniture, office equipment, etc., needed for a business, and in the case of the latter, they are all the goods and services needed to meet customers’ requirements.

The objective of public procurement and contract administration

The purpose of public procurement is to award timely and cost-effective contracts to qualified contractors, suppliers and service providers for the provision of goods, works and services to support national and local administrations and public services, in accordance with the principles and procedures established in the public procurement rules, respecting the Principle of the 5 Cs

The Principle of Correct Procurement – The 5 Cs

I have said it, written it and debated it before:

  • As long as we obtain the right price, in the right quantity, at the right time, at the right quality, in the right place and from the right source, we are technically managing correct procurement.

What is that Principle which is not enshrined by the legislator but which we all aim for?

The Principle of Correctness!

The 5 Cs

  • The CORRECT Quality
  • The CORRECT Quantity
  • The CORRECT Place
  • The CORRECT Time
  • The CORRECT Price

The purpose of contract administration is to provide adequate mechanisms for monitoring and evaluating the performance of contractors, suppliers and service providers in fulfilling their contractual obligations, and to ensure that appropriate action is taken to remedy promptly any deficiencies found in the performance of the contract or in the scope of the contract, as well as in the contractual terms and conditions.

On the basis of their specific objectives, there is a clear distinction between public procurement and contract administration. This distinction, far from diminishing the importance of one as opposed to the other, truly strengthens each, by identifying and focusing on the specific purpose of each.

What are your thoughts on this? Agree? Disagree? Do you have anything to add5?

You can send us6 your answer, colleague7, … at the e-mail addresses: admin@sn-seap.ro ; office@rovest.eu.

Prof. Gabriela ILIN
Public Procurement Specialist and Expert

Dipl. Eng. Ovidiu SLIMAC
Public Procurement Specialist and Expert

Notes

Reference

Ilin, G., & Slimac, O. (2019, May). Lectura 1 – Ce este achiziția publică? [Reading 1 – What is public procurement?]. Revista de Achiziții Publice, (140).

Editorial note

Published materials express the opinions and analyses of the authors who sign them and do not necessarily represent the position of Achiziții Corecte / Correct Procurement. Each author is responsible, in accordance with the law, for the content of their own contribution, including the statements made, the accuracy of information, the identification of sources, and respect for third-party rights. Publishing or making a material available does not constitute adoption or validation of all its opinions and conclusions. The materials are for information purposes and do not replace advice tailored to a particular situation. This note does not exclude liabilities that cannot be excluded by law.