Can human beings be good at procurement?

← Academia · Versiunea în română

Translated from Romanian by Achiziții Corecte. The Romanian text is the reference version.

Ilustrație din articolul „Pot fi ființele umane bune la achiziții ?”

I am Ovidiu Slimac and I am from Timișoara, a city in the west of Romania, a beautiful city that was declared European Capital of Culture for 2021.

I have worked in procurement for more than 15 years. And yes, I am human. I am a human being. And if we believe what researchers and scientists say (British or not 😊), all my buying activities and my buying / purchasing decisions are made emotionally – even the ones I have made for my company.

The question is: being a human being, doesn’t that put me at a disadvantage as a good procurement professional?

Because I want to do a good job, I start every buying process with a few key points, in order to obtain the best and fairest price possible.

I also follow a logical set of steps, or a documented procedure. It is not as if I would go shopping without knowing what I want to buy, what budget I have allocated, what colour the product must be, the quality and quantity I want, and whether there is any chance of it being delivered home for free.

And yet it is hard to stay focused on the purchasing process without letting your attention be drawn by other factors that might ultimately affect your purchase.

For example, watch how people shop in a supermarket. Some shoppers pay close attention to the shopping list in front of them. Others are on the phone while pushing the trolley through the shop, and in most cases they listen carefully to the instructions about what and how to buy given by the person in charge, at the other end of the line.

The more closely they follow the instructions they receive, or their own shopping list, the harder it is for them to let new (and potentially relevant) information into their decision-making.

Today we are in the supermarket with a clearly defined need: we want to buy salami. The CEO – whether the person in charge at the company we work for or the person in charge at the other end of the phone – told us to buy salami and, if there are eggs, to buy 10.

But because we cannot retain so many details, we went back to headquarters not with one salami and 10 eggs, but with 10 salamis!

A person who only follows orders will sometimes make mistakes that a person with a deeper understanding – someone fully engaged and fully aware of their surroundings – will not make.

The same is true of subjective decisions about the quality of a product. When we buy for ourselves, we know our allocated budget and we know the quality that will satisfy our needs, given the funds available.

The beer must be cold, the wine must be aged, and the meat must be well hung.

Perhaps for our biscuits we decide not to buy the popular, cheapest brand but a more expensive one with a special taste. We can afford to take product and brand marketing into account and make a cost / value decision that meets our needs and constraints – all of this to make us happy.

The terms and conditions of purchase also call for value judgements.

Suppose we decide to pay a little more for everything we need from one source, a shop that will deliver it home for free. As professionals in correct procurement, we know that in fact nothing is free and that the cost of delivery has been added to the cost of the products, but we still believe this gives us good value for money, and so we accept the higher prices.

We may also have the chance to earn bonus points or special offers that will benefit us later – this may be hard to quantify, but as human consumers we are able to decide whether each offer is fair value for our money.

Without allowing ‘humanity’ into the public procurement process, I believe we will be too focused on technical procedures. To be leaders of change, we must see the similarities and the differences between what we do when we buy for ourselves and when we simply follow the procedures laid down by the CPO.

My suggestion, therefore, is that we need procurement professionals who are as ‘socially responsible’ as possible. I do not mean social in the sense of a focus on sustainability or green procurement, but rather in a way that lets us make the same value judgements for purchases made in a corporate setting as for those in our personal lives.

As long as we obtain the right price, in the right quantity, at the right time, at the right quality and from the right source, we are technically managing correct procurement.

If we manage to add our human strengths to purchasing decisions, we will gain greater satisfaction from our work and also create greater value for the company as a whole.

Reference

Slimac, O. (2018, April). Pot fi ființele umane bune la achiziții ? [Can human beings be good at procurement?]. Revista de Achiziții Publice, (127).

Editorial note

Published materials express the opinions and analyses of the authors who sign them and do not necessarily represent the position of Achiziții Corecte / Correct Procurement. Each author is responsible, in accordance with the law, for the content of their own contribution, including the statements made, the accuracy of information, the identification of sources, and respect for third-party rights. Publishing or making a material available does not constitute adoption or validation of all its opinions and conclusions. The materials are for information purposes and do not replace advice tailored to a particular situation. This note does not exclude liabilities that cannot be excluded by law.